All you should know before getting a Siamese Algae Eater

I can only assume that your fish tank is still battling that algae problem and you’ve finally decided to employ an “expert” cleaner to fight the intruder plant.

A common recommendation at this point is the true Siamese algae eater which in this subject is somewhat legendary, but is commonly mistaken for the flying fox or the Chinese algae eater which look a lot alike.

Note that these latter two are almost completely useless in an aquarium environment.

What’s more, you are probably considering this fish because it will be beneficial to the cleanliness and ecosystem within your aquarium.

Still, even with a fish as common as this algae eater, many questions are difficult to track down outside of a dedicated fish reading book.

They kind of look like small sharks, but are they aggressive toward their tankmates?

Can they be kept singly or they thrive in groups?

How many do you actually need for a happy fish tank environment?

What is the maximum size of a full-grown SAE?

How complex is their care sheet?

Let’s go through and create a quick summation of the things to know about the Siamese algae eater and the common mistakes when first taking care of this incredibly popular and useful fish.

This fish’s scientific name is Crossocheilus Siamensis and it became popular in the fishkeeping hobby because of its undying appetite for algae.

In fact, it will consume almost all types of algal growth, including hair algae.

As you may already know, unfortunately, algae are a form of pest vegetation that’s difficult to eradicate, even after repeatedly taking measures against it.

The algae eater in question, however, is constantly on the look for food.

This has made the SAE a wonderful addition to most aquarium setups as it’s a loveable fish in its own right but is also useful in a balanced ecosystem.

Quick Facts About the Siamese Algae Eater

By Irecruitfish

Originating in the Malayan Peninsula and Thailand, Siamese algae eaters are bottom-dwelling fish native to small streams and rivers.

Sometimes they populate flooded forests where they feed on the algae that dominate in these ecosystems. They work together in large schools picking clean algae growth on rocks and plants in the waters.

They are technically part of the carp family, Cyprinidae, and known as Crossocheilus Siamensis.

They can be easily confused with their cousin the Crossocheilus Oblongus which are much less helpful to have in an aquarium.

Sometimes you can find them falsely labeled as a “Siamese Flying Fox” in the aquarium trade.

SAEs have a brownish-beige coloration, except their nearly translucent clear caudal fin, and a black stripe that runs the length of their body that just brushes the before mentioned fin.

Despite their name, these so-called algae eaters are true omnivorous fish feasting on algae, phytoplankton, and even zooplanktons.

Their diet and behavior change depending on the food sources in their environment, making them incredibly adaptable when compared to other algae eaters.

Interestingly, the true Siamese Algae Eater does not have a swim bladder for buoyancy. The lack of hydrostatic organs is a common trait in bottom-dwelling fish.

This means these fish are nearly in constant motion in their environment as to not completely sink and maintain buoyancy. They are, therefore, quite efficient at their jobs and interesting to watch darting around for their next meal.

Their diet mainly consists of hair-like algae though they are omnivores by nature so they will feed on most commercially available fish foods as well.

The difference between a true Siamese Algae Eater and a flying foxfish or a Chinese algae eater

It’s important to know the difference between a real Siamese algae eater and its lookalikes.

The “imposters” are often purchased and sold accidentally due to a lack of knowledge on the subject by either the purchaser or the store itself.

Here’s how to tell apart a true Siamese algae Eater from a flying fox fish or a Chinese algae eater:

The difference between a True Siamese algae eater and a Flying Fox, by far the most commonly confused, can be seen easily in their fins. You can tell a real Siamese algae eater apart from the flying fox fish by its fins, which are almost entirely clear, with only a bit of black reaching its caudal (tail) fin.

That being said, here’s a visual representation of the differences, that may further help you with the identification:

The Flying Fox will have black on both its bottom and top fins, which the true Siamese algae eaters will never have.

If you see black on either the top fins or bottom it is NOT a Crossocheilus Siamensis, no matter what it is labeled as.

As far as Chinese algae eaters (CAE) go, identification mistakes are less often made but they do happen.

The black stripe is much more ragged on a CAE and only looks similar to a completely untrained eye.

This is not to say a fish store won’t confuse them. They deal in a large amount of fish and many of the workers aren’t fully trained to identify these similar-looking species. Beware of this common pitfall.

Siamese algae eaters also have a somewhat shark-like appearance. People actually add them to their freshwater “shark tanks” full of other fish with similar looks.

Here’s a shot from one such shark tank where a Siamese algae eater is schooling with Dension barbs:

By SilasX93

A full-grown specimen and suggested aquarium size

So, we’ve covered the behavior of the Siamese Algae Eater and its identification but now it’s time to talk size. This is one of those fish that grow much larger than you might expect at first glance.

Here’s how big the Siamese algae eaters get in an aquarium environment:

A true Siamese algae eater grows to a maximum size of about 6″ (16 cm) in an ideal environment. However, to get one to reach its full length of 6 inches it has to be well cared for and in an aquarium large enough to support its swimming needs.

It is generally recommended to have at least a 30-gallon tank and 36 inches of vertical aquarium length to fully let the Siamese algae eaters stretch out.

Siamese Algae Eaters are indeed schooling fish and need to have sufficient room to move about.

Possibly more for mature ones as you will need to have them schooling together at full size.

Here’s a photo of fully grown SAE that looks quite bulky:

By Cezh_work_GSD_Scout

Recommended foods for a balanced diet for Siamese Algae Eaters

As important, for growing your fish healthily is maintaining the proper nutritious food for them as a balanced diet will ensure the longevity of your algae eaters.

Their name obviously suggests that they feed mostly on algae.

This is true, but there is some nuance to this that needs to be accounted for.

To supply a Siamese algae eater with adequate food sources you should consider that:

Siamese algae eaters enjoy eating green hair algae to an extent that some fishkeepers cultivate that on purpose. However, you should be supplementing its menu with commercially bought algae wafers, live food, catfish pellets, and meaty foods as well.

A true SAE will destroy algae clusters quicker than you may expect. I have listed them among my top recommendations when it comes to a quick and efficient clean of an aquarium.

It is never a good idea to count on algae alone when it comes to this fish’s diet because that would result in poor health and vitamin deficiency.

However, take note that if they are provided a diet too rich in proteins they may forget algae entirely and begin to subsist solely on commercial foods.

Give them algae and let them forage about the tank. Provide them with meatier foods sparingly as more of a treat from time to time.

I have seen some people suggesting to half-starve the creatures to ensure they will always be on the lookout for algae.

I find this approach a little extreme and would not recommend it, as it somehow feels like exploiting.

It is possible to stimulate the appetite for algae in an SAE without torturing it with fasting periods.

It has been my experience that keeping the proportion of vegetables to meat at 80% to 20% in the algae eater’s diet will produce good results, without compromising on vitamin intake.

You can experiment with this somewhat, just be sure not to overfeed if you wish for them to remain effective aquarium cleaners.

Will a Siamese Algae Eater consume black beard or other hard hair algae?

The Black beard algae are one of the most difficult hair algae species to get rid of.

It will survive treatments of most common algaecides and this makes it quite the pain for aquarium owners. Luckily, the SAE has your back here.

Real Siamese algae eaters possess an appetite for and will consume large quantities of black beard algae. In fact, they will eat all hair algae, which makes them significantly beneficial to most home aquariums.

This picture was taken while a Siamese algae eater eats leftover black algae:

By mervyn96

And here’s video proof of that on YouTube.

Truly, there isn’t a product out there that works as effectively as a real Siamese algae eater, but that’s only if they have the appetite going.

What do I mean by that?

There are occasions on which the Siamese algae eaters won’t have the desire to eat black beard algae.

If there are not many other aquatic plants and the Carbon Dioxide level in the aquarium is low, the beard algae become stiff and unappetizing for algae eaters.

In that case, you’ll need to first supply your aquarium with some more freshwater plants or at least add more CO2.

This will affect the black hair algae in a way that it will become easier to chew on and get eaten by the algae grazers.

It’s also worth noting that there’s not a distinctive time period before the Crossocheilus Siamensis starts developing an appetite for black algae.

If your Siamese algae eater won’t show interest in grazing on this particular type of algae, it may mean that the fish has either been raised with mainly commercial-grade food or the black beard algae is too stiff.

Don’t think about it too much though, as this is rarely the case.

Be sure to keep their diet regulated properly as mentioned above, and soon after introducing this fish to a system, not only the black but all hair algae will no longer be a problem.

Perceived temperament of the Siamese algae eater

For the most part, the Siamese algae eater is not an aggressive fish. It’s classified as peaceful and it will not harm other inhabitants in a fish tank.

There is, however, one caveat to this.

The males are somewhat territorial among each other. This happens mainly if the school is not large enough.

They need either be with no others of their kind or in a fairly large group of about 5 or more. Because of this temperament trait, it’s advisable to purchase only female Siamese algae eaters if you want a group. However, I strongly recommend getting a single specimen over a group to avoid issues in the future.

Anyway, you can only tell the females apart from the males when the fish is mature.

The female Siamese Algae Eater would have around 30% more body mass than a male one, for the same body length.

This would mean that females appear more round, whereas male Siamese Algae Eaters appear more elongated.

Here’s a photo of a pair of Siamese algae eaters swimming side by side:

By Drewet88

Though it would probably the better option, picking females over males is not a necessity. If you’re getting just one Siamese Algae Eater for your tank, then the gender of the fish does not matter at all.

In either case, these algae eaters are perfect for a community aquarium with other peaceful aquatic inhabitants, and will not harm other fish species.

Recommended tank companions

A tank with just SAE’s in it will do just fine, however, this isn’t most people’s ideal set up.

Caution should be taken, as even though the SAE is a relatively peaceful fish it will not do well if there are aggressive tank mates in the aquarium.

Here are the generally recommended tank mates for a Siamese algae eater:

Ideal companions for a Siamese algae eater are that of other community type fish. Your Gouramis, schools of Barbs, Tetras or Danios, Angel Fish, Guppies, swordtails, or cory cats will all do fine alongside your algae eater as tank mates.

If you’d like you can check my list on the best community fish for more details.

Other Siamese algae eaters, are also great companions to keep around as they will naturally school together, but make sure you pick mostly females.

Beware of territorial bottom-feeding fish, they will harass the peaceful SAE and potentially cause harm to it.

This means no Red Tail Sharks, for example, which are the classic example of this unhealthy interaction.

If you have a pleco in there, make sure it has a shy personality and that it remains small in size, such as the rubber lipped pleco. For more ideas you can also check my list on the best small pleco fish.

Anyway, for Pleco/SAE combination to work, it’s important to maintain a temperature range that’s healthy for both species. Most plecos are the type of fish that prefers slightly colder aquariums, but the temperature range overlaps with the recommended one for an SAE. Aim for 75 to 76 °F (23.9 to 24.4 °C) in this setup.

Cichlids are also problematic, though most of them should be kept in a species only tank anyways.

The exception to this is the somewhat peaceful angelfish which does just fine around SAEs.

Other non-fish companions work exceptionally well – snails and shrimp are all great choices if you’d like to add some diversity to the movements around the tank.

Where to buy one?

The Siamese algae eaters are widely available at most physical aquarium stores, as they are very useful and popular fish.

Generally, you will find them simply labeled for sale under “algae eater” which causes the problems of misidentification with CAE’s and the Flying Foxfish.

Be sure to be on the lookout for the black stripe and clear fins and you should have no problems with getting the right species.

Don’t always trust the label, use your knowledge to identify a real Siamese algae eater.

Most are priced fairly low at around 5 dollars, though a larger specimen may cost more if it’s from a reputable breeder.

Your other option would be to buy a Siamese Algae Eater from an online fish store or a local vendor. I’d recommend getting yours from a place that specializes in selling freshwater aquarium fish in particular. I’ve selected the best ones in the link.

Anyway here’s a photo of someone getting theirs for only $2.49:

By mia0416

Tips for taking proper care of Siamese Algae Eaters

As you can see from what I’ve covered so far these fish are fairly low maintenance and can be a huge help to any fish tank that doesn’t house aggressive bottom feeders.

The big thing to reiterate, however, is to be sure that the species is indeed a true Crossocheilus Siamensis and not one of its less helpful cousins and lookalikes.

Here are tips on selecting and caring for a Siamese algae eater:

  • Make sure your algae eater has clear dorsal and lower fins with only a small bit of black reaching its caudal fins.
  • Provide the SAEs with enough room to school, eat, and grow properly. The bare minimum fish tank size is 30 gallons and 36 inches in length.
  • Avoid an overabundance of protein-rich foods, as they will ignore the algae if regularly fed with that.
  • A properly taken care of SAE will reach around 6″ in length, so be sure to accommodate that level of growth.
  • Do not place this algae eater with aggressive fish, they only do well in a peaceful environment.
  • The fish must either be kept alone or within a school of 5 or more, as territorial disputes can happen otherwise.
  • Remember that an SAE does not have a swim bladder, so it will move around quite a bit while foraging for food, which may stress slow-swimming fish.
  • Have a lid installed on your fish tank, as these fish are well-known jumpers.

If you take into account all of this you should have little to no issue introducing a Siamese algae eater into your home aquatic system.

Here’s how a healthy and well-cared for Crossocheilus Siamensis specimen looks like:

By mwardwell

Are you ready to get one?

Despite me going on at length on how to take care of the Siamese algae eater fish, they’re really not a complex species to look after.

I only want to properly inform beginner aquarium enthusiasts to ensure a beneficial relationship between them, the fish tank owner, and the fish that will act as an incredibly effective cleaner for their set up.

Honestly, you will love yours once they have acclimated to your tank.

It really may surprise you how quickly even an algae-infested tank can be picked and cleaned by these remarkable fish.

It’s quite enjoyable watching as well, as they’ll roam around the fish tank restlessly.

Leave a comment if you think there’s something I did not mention or you want more help.

Sharing is caring!

22 thoughts on “All you should know before getting a Siamese Algae Eater”

  1. This is lovely information but with all of my years with fish and my 24 fish tanks all with 1 SAE in them. My tanks range from 45 gallons to a specially custom made 1000 gallon built into my wall. Every SAE I own and have owned has always been territorial males and females. I have made the mistake many times. They are fine till about a certain size and then they will get very territorial and kill eachother. They also get bigger then what’s listed and yes I’m 100% sure mine were SAE. There only ment to be together while breeding. They also can’t be together with Cory catfish because that’s another algae fish. Some of the fish you listed also need different water adjustment then them.

    • Hi,

      Thank you for the feedback, much appreciated! I’ve seen tanks with SAEs that were 6-7 years old and no aggression was observed, but I do acknowledge that it may not always be the case. This has just been my experience.

      As for their size, I also agree that 6 inches are not a hard limit. I’ve seen some anomalies when the Siamese Algae Eater was looked after in a very large and clean tank. However, in my experience 6 is the most common size and after that, they grow very very slowly (if any).

      Finally, I don’t think corydoras eat algae? They’ll eat leftover foods and wafers but not algae. They do not resemble the shape of a Siamese Algae Eater and I’ve never had issues with keeping both. This is interesting.

      Also, some of the tank mates I have listed are very adaptable to different water parameters and this is why it may seem like there are disparities.

      Let me know if there’s anything else.

      Thanks again for the kind words and for sharing your experience with me.

      Best,
      Momchil

  2. Thanks for the information as I just bought one for my tank, went in to fish shop to buy a new heater for a tank and saw the S.A,E and bought it .so now I know I did the right thing , just love it in my tank .😁

    • It’s a great fish!

  3. Hi. I have a 10 gal tank and need a good brown algae eater. Can I get one SAE with 3 guppies, 2 tetras and 1 betta?

    • Hi,

      A 10-gallon tank is way too small for a Siamese Algae Eater.

      With your setup, I’d recommend trying either some Amano Shrimp or Nerite Snails. Both eat brown algae.

      Amano shrimp may not breed in freshwater and if your Betta is aggressive it may pick at them.

      Nerite snails are chill and cool but may start laying eggs all over your tank (that won’t hatch and may look unsightly).

      Also, brown algae sometimes sort themselves out with time, if your tank is relatively new.

      Hope this helps,

      Good luck!

      Momchil

  4. I have a 29 gal. tank with an algae problem. I have 7 raspaduras, 4 zebra loaches, 1 yo yo loach. Do you recommend the Chinese algae eater or something else? I’ve tried feeding less, keeping light off less, and algaefix. Thank you.

    • Hi,

      DON’T get a Chinese Algae Eater, but a Siamese Algae Eater. Chinese ones become very aggressive once they mature…

      Other than that, try lowering the Phosphate in the system. Test your tap water with your liquid test kit and see if it’s a source of Phosphate (if you use that for water changes).

      You could get a simple Phosphate absorber to do the rest.

      Any level of Phosphate higher than 1 ppm could sprout algae growth.

      Another thing to limit the available nutrients that algae feed on is by introducing some floating plants to the tank. They grow aggressively and therefore use a lot of the dissolved nutrients in the water.

      Hope this helps!

      Let me know if you have more questions.

      – Momchil

  5. Can Crossocheilus Siamensis live with a red line shark

    • Hi Ronni,

      Yes, Roseline Torpedo sharks and Siamese Algae Eaters get along just fine. You’d need to make sure you have at least 6 Roseline sharks to minimize the possibility of aggression. You also need to make sure you get a true Siamese Algae Eater since a Flying Fox can be more aggressive towards other shark-looking tank mates. In many cases, the Siamese Algae Eaters would even school with the Roseline Sharks as these species are closely related.

      Hope this helps!

  6. Could one of these siamese algae eaters be kept with fancy goldfish?

    • Hi,

      Sure, you can put the two together under the following conditions:

      Read about the prefered water temperature of your goldfish. The Siamese Algae Eaters prefer to live in water temperatures of between 75 and 79 °F.

      Adust the tank’s temperature so that it covers both the prefered range of the goldfish and the Siamese algae eater. Adjustment in water temperatures should happen slowly and BEFORE you introduce the algae eater in the tank.

      Hope this helps!

      Good luck!

  7. A lot of good information in your article.
    I have 2 of them in a 240ltr tank with 12 African Malawi lake Cichlids and 2 Bristle noses and they seem to do very well. All the fish seem to mind their business, except of course the Cichlids, which are chasing each other and harassing the Bristlenoses from time to time.
    The SAE are quick enough to get away from any aggressive fish and there are enough hiding places. But the SAE don’t really mind any other species in my case.

    • Thanks for sharing your story.

      It’s always beneficial when other people who also have hands-on experience share their experiences.

      Thanks for that!

  8. thank you for such an excellent article! I would love to get an SAE to add to my pretty peaceful acara type tank, but I think it will be a struggle to find one grown up enough to not become dinner. I’ve only seen these types of fish selling at very small sizes. they sure are adorable!

    • Thanks so much for the warm feedback and I can’t help but agree that SAEs are super cute (and excellent cleaners at that)!!!

      Stay well!

  9. How to tell females from males?

    • Females have a more round body, whereas males look more elongated. You can only tell the 2 apart in mature fish though.

  10. This is a very informative and helpful article. Thank you for your excellent work! I would like to address a couple things you mention though.

    True SAE are not easy to find in pet stores here in the North East US.
    I have been looking for years and never found them in any of the big chain pet stores or independent stores. They only stock Chinese Algae Eaters and Flying Fox. I recently lucked out and found some in a small family store, but they were marked Flying Foxes.

    I was not 100% sure they were SAE because as I watched them at the pet store, sometimes it looked like the black stripe continued through the entire tail, and sometimes not. Often fish colors fade when they are stressed, which is what I believe was happening. (Being shipped long distances, dumped into new tanks/water, and having a big dumb human staring at them like some hungry predator might?).

    The last thing is that you state a couple times to buy female SAE, but you never say how to distinguish male from female. I have never come across this in any other articles or videos either.

    • Hi and thank you for your input.

      Generally, 9 times out of 10, SAEs will be mislabeled in the fish store. Literally, almost every time. A good rule of thumb if you’re on a hunt for Siamese algae eaters is to check all the fish labeled as “algae eaters” or flying foxes etc. even Chinese algae eaters…

      Onto your second point – you can differentiate females from males in mature fish only. Mature Siamese Algae Eaters (2.5 or more years old) will have different body shape depending on the sex.

      A female Siamese algae eater will have around 30% more body mass than a male who’s the same length. This means that males appear as more elongated, where the females are rounder.

      Honestly, in the article I made it sound like it’s very important to pick females over males. Truth be told, although it would probably be better, it’s not necessary.

      Also, I’ll take the fact that you haven’t read this in other articles or videos as a compliment. From what I’ve seen there’s a tendency for other aquarium blogs to just re-write or paraphrase the same information, copying from one another.

      I try my best not to do that and provide unique info. I’m using personal experience + offline resources when I dig into a subject etc. Obviously, I will not represent the info differently for the sake of uniqueness, if something is as it is – I will say it.

      Hope this helps, happy fish keeping!

      • Would one SAE be enough for my 60 gallon?. It has a break out of BBA that all methods seem to fail in getting rid of.

        Many thanks

        • Hi there,

          I’d get at least 2 for that tank size. But as far as I’m concerned, having 1 SAE is better than not having any. By the way, have you tried lowering the phosphates?

          Regards

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.