To flourish freshwater aquatic plants need a good source of light and an extensive palette of nutrients. For the latter, there must be some sort of aquarium soil substrate that would suffice as a source of plant food, right?
Not so fast.
Substrates and their relation to aquarium plants can get complicated for the newcomer without a comprehensive guide. To achieve a beautiful underwater aquascape you’ll need to consider more than one brand and their respective properties.
The best product for a planted aquarium should definitely be a nutrient-rich substrate, but how will that affect other aquatic inhabitants?
Different materials, aside from sand or gravel, can affect water parameters. You need to take this into account if you’re planning to create a planted underwater garden and add an expensive species of shrimp to that tank, for example.
Would a DIY approach be adequate then? What will suit your live plants best while being safe for everyone else in the aquarium?
|Substrate name:||Key Nutrients:||Best Price:|
|1. ADA Aqua Soil AMAZONIA||Yes||Amazon|
|2. CaribSea Eco-Complete Planted Aquarium||No||Amazon|
|3. Black Diamond Blasting Sand||No||Locally|
|4. Mr.Aqua Planting Substrate||Yes||Amazon|
|5. Fluval Plant and Shrimp Stratum||Yes||Amazon|
|6. Dennerle Scaper’s soil||Yes||Amazon|
|8. Seachem Flourite||No||Amazon|
Supplying a planted aquarium with the RIGHT substrate: an A-to-Z Guide
To make the right choice you should be familiar with all the aspects of the different types of aquarium substrates. It may be a good idea to bookmark this page, as you’ll see that it’s not a tiny bit of information. Have a look at this guide when choosing a substrate for your planted tank and consider the following:
1. Substrate Material
To comprehend aquarium substrates and how they affect plants you first need to know your material. There are tons of varieties out there, but generally, it all boils down to a couple of proven and well-understood ones. The substrates suitable for aquarium use are:
- Sand. – All in all, sand is fine grade rock minerals. It has no nutritional value for your plants.
- Gravel. – Same as sand in composition, but with much larger grains (anything above 2.0 mm). The size of the grains has different advantages and disadvantages in the aquarium. You’ll find more on that below in this guide.
- Baked Clay-based products. – These are products derived from baked clay. They won’t contain 100% clay.
- Regular soil. – This includes topsoil and potting soil. Topsoil is just dirt from your garden, which is basically a mixture of sand or gravel and compost or other organic materials. Potting soil can be made at home and is usually peat (partially decayed organic matter) combined with other additives such as sawdust and volcanic glass.
- Aquasoil. – Aquasoil is baked regular soil that forms granules. It has the combined advantages of most other substrates, except perhaps their aesthetics. The grain size allows for super easy maintenance and the nutrients will feed your aquatic plants.
These are the 5 main types of substrates for a fish tank with or without plants, classified by material.
2. Nutritional potential
Plants need a number of macro and micronutrients to thrive. To classify substrates relevant to their role in aquatic plant growth we can establish 2 main classes:
- Inert substrates – Inert substrates include gravel, sand, and baked clay products. These are the ones that do not provide nutritional value in a planted tank.
Why would anyone want anything of the like in their aquarium? Many reasons – visual appeal, pH and KH buffering, a weight that allows for easier planting and stable plant stems, controlling pore spacing, which contributes to better substrate oxygenation, water flow around plant’s root systems.
- Depleting substrates – Depleting substrates are the ones that have high nutritional value and thus directly promote vegetative growth in a planted aquarium.
Because these come with a limited amount of organic matter they will need to be replenished with time, as they will slowly decompose. These include commercial-grade aquasoils and regular soils.
Despite the advertising, some commercial substrates for planted tanks will include the nutritional elements in the form of bound molecules.
These will not be able to break down and reach your hungry plants’ roots.
Technically this is not false advertising, but it’s not of use to your aquatic vegetation as well.
You can recognize these by their manufacturer’s promise to not break down with time (such as Seachem Flourite).
For this reason, to optimally grow whatever plants you’d still want to add a liquid fertilizer or root tabs when using these substrates.
3. Cation Exchange Capacity Value (CEC)
Some substrates used in planted fish tanks will have more Cation Exchange Capacity than others.
Cations are positively charged ions.
Aquatic plants employ these ions and turn them into energy and growth.
A higher CEC means that the substrate will be able to attract and hold valuable nutrients from the environment and readily provide them to aquatic plants.
Pretty much like a magnet. Think of it as an inherent characteristic of soils.
Generally, more CEC does not equal more readily available plant food, because you still need to “charge” the substrate with additional fertilizers.
That being said, aquasoil and other substrates rich in organic matter have the highest CEC, and by degrading they charge themselves.
Clay-based substrates do not have high CEC (or at least nowhere near aquasoils) so if you want to take advantage of that you’d want to charge them by dosing additional fertilizers anyway.
Calcined Montmorillonite Clay (for example Safe-T-Sorb) has the highest CEC from the inert baked-clay substrates, which is still 4 times less than peat or aquasoils.
4. Substrate weight
The weight of your substrate of choice for your planted tank plays a role in the management of your greens.
Lighter substrates will obviously get stirred more easily by your livestock.
This, in turn, creates a rather constant unpleasant view and the particles could also clog or even damage the impeller of your filter.
However, what I find most annoying with lighter substrates is how difficult planting becomes.
Aquatic plants do like to float and if you’re dealing with tender species such as the dwarf hair grass, for example, you’ll have a very hard time keeping it down on the bottom.
This creates the need for constant replanting and even surgeon precision won’t be of much help here.
Heavier substrates allow easy planting and therefore management of the aquarium’s bottom.
If you ever need to replant or rescape your tank (which eventually happens) you won’t be annoyed to death when trying to anchor down your greens.
5. Size of the grains
Though fine sand may appear appealing as a bottom cover it will actually impact the health of your plants’ roots.
Finer grain size results in compacting, which leads to less oxygen available for the root systems.
It also hinders other gas exchanges between the water column and the substrate, which can result in harmful gases accumulating and killing your aquatic plants.
These are called anaerobic pockets and are the result of trapped waste decomposing in an anaerobic (no oxygen) environment.
A compacted substrate also applies pressure and can seriously damage plants with more fragile roots.
On the other hand, large grain size can prevent smaller roots from successfully spreading and you may also find it difficult to anchor down your tinier plants stably.
Another thing to consider with a coarse grade substrate is that it also creates “pockets” which can hide decomposing waste, that may overwhelm the biofilter and cause a spike in ammonia or nitrites.
A substrate that’s porous provides more surface area for beneficial bacteria to develop.
Aquariums that have substrates with good porosity can arguably hold larger colonies of nitrifying bacteria and therefore are able to handle more livestock if needed.
7. Possibly altering water parameters
Aquasoils that contain quality organic matter (such as peat) will decrease the pH of your water.
This should be taken into consideration when planning a plants tank because it can affect fish or other livestock.
Swings in pH are stressful for aquarium inhabitants.
The acidity of the water increases on a logarithmic scale. This means that water with a pH of 5 is more than 10 times more acidic than one with a pH value of 6.
These auqasoils will also strip your water from KH (carbonate hardness) indirectly.
In the context of fishkeeping KH equals your aquarium water’s buffering strength.
The more KH it has, the better it will withstand changes in its acidity.
Buffering capacity is the power to stabilize.
High KH in water means that it will be difficult to increase or decrease the pH levels.
In water chemistry laymen terms you should imagine it like a sponge.
Whenever you add acid (lower the pH) your KH “absorbs” that acid for its most part.
However, the more acid you add the more the sponge gets “used up”.
Essentially at some point, your KH will fall down to 0 and then the pH will start to fall as well because your aquarium water will lose its buffering capacity.
At this point changing the acidity levels will be very easy, but it will also be more susceptible to swings.
Different aquasoils will aim to bring down the pH to different values, but all of them will generally target the 6.5 to 7 pH range because that’s where most aquatic plants feel comfortable.
In case I did not make that obvious – inert substrates will rarely if at all affect your fish tank’s water parameters.
But why that exact range?
Potent aquasoils such as ADA Amazonia are designed to leach ammonium in the water.
That’s a good source of nitrogen for aquatic plants and they prefer it to nitrates for their N-uptake.
Mind that’s not ammonia (NH3), but ammoniUM (NH4+).
Note that ammonium will show as ammonia on most test kits (such as this popular one), so don’t be baffled if it’s relatively high, but your fish seem to thrive. It’s all about acidity.
8. Visual appeal
Visual appeal is definitely a factor when it comes to aquarium substrates.
After all, the idea behind a planted tank is to make things as pretty as possible.
Some depleting substrates will have a better appearance than others, same as with inert substrates.
Generally, inert substrates such as sand and gravel do look better in a planted tank setup.
Black Diamond Blasting Sand (BDBS) is black-ish and has a slight glitter to it.
It usually is a nice background for colorful fish and shrimps.
Pool sand has a mellow light yellow color, that complements greens and red-ish rockwork.
Because of these advantages, fishkeepers often “cap” nutrient-rich substrates with an inert one (though that’s not the only reason behind capping).
9. Possible setups and combinations
When planning for your planted tank setup you can go with a couple of different options. The possible substrate setups and layers for an aquarium with plants are:
- Inert substrate with fertilizer dosing. Since this substrate layer won’t provide any nutrients for your plants you’d want to dose with either root tabs or liquid fertilizers in the water column. Inert substrates are beautiful, super easy to clean and manage, and don’t ever deplete or require changing. Ideally, you’d want your inert substrate to have good porosity, not too fine grains, and decent specific gravity to make anchoring plants in it easy. I mention some good candidates below. In my experience root tabs work best here if you’re not diligent enough to dose liquid ferts every other day.
- Commercial depleting substrate. Having a nutrient-rich substrate such as aquasoil will give you the most advantage to growing lush vegetation in the aquarium. These substrates will modify your pH and feed your aquatic plants really well. The downside here is that these are more expensive because they follow a special technology in their making. Baking organic matter into decently-sized granules with appropriate weight and having the right macro and micronutrients results in very easy management and fantastic plant growth. Another thing to consider here is that they will eventually deplete and will need a reload. The guy who introduced the Amano shrimps to the hobby, Takashi Amano, who is also legendary when it comes to planted tanks and aquascapes used to advise that you reload your depleting aquasoil at least once a year. He used to manage heavily planted tanks with difficult-to-grow species, so take that advice with a grain of salt. The replenishing period will greatly depend on the amount and needs of your particular plants, so for you, it will probably take even longer than that. If you want to have a heavily planted tank with various plant species, but don’t want excruciating substrate management then aquasoils are for you.
- Garden dirt or potting soil. This is the option that I were to stay away from if I were new to planted tanks and substrates. Yes, garden or potting soils both have tremendous potential in growing aquatic plants, but the maintenance will be a real pain. They get stirred up easily and if you go this road you’re essentially sentencing your aquarium to have muddy water all the time. Some expert fishkeepers do aim for the “dirted tank” on purpose, but that’s not for everyone, because of the aforementioned reasons. Being nutrient-rich, garden dirt will deplete over time. It will also modify the acidity of your fish tank water. Avoid soils rich in compost and clay. Peat is your friend. Know that every soil will be different (especially topsoils) and if you want to achieve the same effect, you should supply yours from one and the same place.
- Garden soil capped with an inert substrate. This DIY substrate setup is a favorite to those who’d like to be frugal but are willing to keep up with the maintenance while producing marvelous plant growth. The cap resolves virtually all maintenance issues that come with using dirt. Capping with inert sand or gravel prevents the soil below from stirring and dirting the water column. It also makes planting way easier. Replanting and uprooting can be a bit tricky though because there’s still a chance of creating a mess. Pruning or rescaping often require uprooting and if you’re not super careful you may end up with swamp-like aquarium water. With a good canister filter in work, it should be fine in a couple of hours. The cap also gives the cosmetic advantage while it’s easier to vacuum. Use 2 parts of soil and 1 part cap. Be very careful not to mix the two layers as it will defeat the purpose. This do-it-yourself approach can be really inexpensive, while extremely effective if done right.
- Commercial depleting substrate capped with an inert substrate. In my experience, this is one of the best possible substrate setups for a fish tank with plants. Commercial aquasoils have tons of advantages and give one of the best plant growth in the hobby, while completely eliminating the disadvantages of dirt (such as management). Combine that with a cap of a beautiful, porous inert substrate that holds plants well and emphasizes their color and you’ll get the most of your planted aquarium. Again, use 2 parts of aquasoil and 1 part inert substrate. Gravel caps have very specific properties that I will discuss further in my reviews below.
Now that you have a decent understanding of how to use different substrates in your aquarium, ask yourself:
“Why will I be using it?”
10. The aquatic plants that you want to grow
If you’ve done your homework on planted tanks you already know that your choice of aquatic plants plays a major role in setting up the whole system.
Besides a decent substrate, to optimally grow these you also need decent lighting, with LEDs being the practice-proven top choice (visit the link to my help-guide on these if you’re in the middle phase of your research). Choosing the right lights is just half the equation for explosive growth.
That being said, you should know a couple of things when considering a substrate for your plants:
- Plants with tender roots will have a difficult time spreading their rooting systems in coarser substrates. If you want to grow carpeting aquatic plants such as Dwarf Hairgrass, you’d probably want to have a 1.5 mm to 2 mm sandy cap. Carpet plants often use special roots called runners, which eventually form an intertwined underground system.
- Plants with strong deep-spreading rooting systems would need coarser substrates. For best results combine commercial aquasoil or dirt, capped with pea gravel. The depth of the substrate should be appropriate with these (don’t go over 3.5 inches in total).
- Easier plants that don’t require much in terms of nutrients will do well in inert substrates if you dose fertilizers on the side. This is the recommended setup for inexperienced fishkeepers. Note that growing easy plants does not mean a lightly-planted tank. You can have lush green underwater foliage with an inert substrate as long as you pick your plants wisely.
- Medium-demanding plants will benefit from a commercial depleting substrate such as aquasoil. If your plants require a little more nutrients your planted tank will definitely do better with a commercial aquasoil. It can be done with inert substrates too, but you’d need to dose root tabs AND liquid fertilizers for optimal growth.
- Harder-to-grow plants will definitely require aquasoil or garden dirt. In general, all plants will show fewer health issues and faster growth in soils, than inert substrates. If you’re after difficult plants consider either pure or capped commercial aquasoil. This is the recommended setup for hobbyists new to demanding plants. If you’re going down the garden dirt road, make sure the layer’s capped as well. With these plants, you’d likely still need to dose additional fertilizers, as no substrate will be enough on its own to grow them.
What are the Best Planted Aquarium Substrates – reviewing the 8 top choices
The best aquarium substrate should include key nutrients to feed your live plants, be easy to manage, remain stable and provide a reasonable bed for growing beneficial bacteria. Mentioned below are only products that stand out by strongly fulfilling one or more of these criteria. Here are the best-performing substrates for a planted tank:
1. ADA Aqua Soils – Premium Growth
What I’m about to say here is my opinion, though it’s generally agreed upon by many other aquarists.
The ADA Aquasoil Amazonia products are definitely the best commercial substrates for a planted tank on the market right now.
The soil contains important macro and micronutrients and feeds your plants over long periods of time.
This brand of substrate arguably shows the best foliage growth in a planted tank setup.
It’s very ammonia-rich and it releases huge amounts during the first couple of weeks.
This way they provide the most value for your plants while being safe to fish and shrimp.
For this reason, If your water is neutral or alkaline (7+ pH) it’s recommended that you introduce the Amazonia products to the aquarium before adding fish and shrimp and let the nitrogen cycle do its work for 2 to 3 weeks.
After the tank has completely cycled the substrate will still leach ammonium, but your pH will now be lower and it won’t cause you issues.
Aquatic plants prefer to get their nitrogen from ammonium (NH4+) rather than nitrates (NO3).
This makes ADA Aquasoil a very competitive product and a preferred choice by many planted tank enthusiasts, be it experts or newcomers.
If you cap it with a layer of an inert substrate the residual ammonium won’t ever get to your water column and it will be properly handled by the good bacteria and the roots of your plants.
The grain size just about perfect to let water flow and also has a decent weight that will allow easy planting. It’s ideal for both aquatic plants with large and small roots.
This soil has outstanding porosity that allows for tons of bio-filtering bacteria to be grown.
Because of its degrading organic components, it will deplete over a period of 12 to 24 months.
The period depends on how dense and demanding the plants in your aquarium are.
After that, you’d need to add more (meaning another ammonia spike and time for cycling).
When its nutritional value melts away you can also start adding root tabs or liquid fertilizer instead of replenishing. That’s according to your taste.
This commercial substrate will lower the pH and get rid of the KH in your aquarium water.
Slightly acidic water is usually preferred by many tropical fish and plants.
Before deciding on this product do research on the fish you plan to house in your planted aquarium and what acidity they thrive in.
Make sure their preferred pH levels align with these of ADA Aquasoils.
The ADA Amazonia substrate will generally lower your pH to about 6.8 or so.
There are 5 ADA Aquasoil substrates on the market right now. Here’s a general summary of each and their key differences:
- ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia – Has the MOST significant impact on plants. Leaches the most ammonium at first. Definitely let it cycle before adding fish or shrimp if current pH levels read above 7. Has a dark (unpleasant in my opinion) brown color and it will cloud your water upon introduction. Can initially induce algae, because of high-nutritional value, but with time it will balance itself out. I recommend this one if you want to get the most of your plants. Will increase the acidity to about 6.8 pH.
- ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia II – Leaches roughly twice as little ammonium than Amazonia. Will grow your plants almost as much. May need cycling, depending on current pH levels. Won’t cloud the water when being added or rescaping. Is more starter-friendly. Will increase the acidity to about 6.4 pH.
- ADA Aqua Soil Amazonia LIGHT – Has roughly 4 times less ammonium content than Amazonia. Will release roughly 5 times more Nitrates. Has roughly 50% less phosphate than Amazonia. Will increase the acidity to about 6.7 pH. This one will produce less growth than Amazonia, but it will also keep algae under control in the initial stage. Good for heavily-planted tanks with low to medium demanding plants.
- ADA Aqua Soil Africana – Leaches no ammonium. Has little to no nutritional value for your plants (only provides a small amount of nitrates). Has harder granules. Has a red-ish coloration. Will significantly increase the acidity of water to about 5.9 pH.
- ADA Aqua Soil Malaya – Has no nutritional value to your plants and leaches no ammonium. Has soft granules and a lighter yellowish color. Will impact the acidity in your tank the most bringing it to 5.5 or in some cases even lower.
Okay, now that you know the differences you should be absolutely sure in your pick.
If your tank is going to revolve around lush green growth that includes carpeting plants I recommend going for the Amazonia.
The only cons that I would like to mention are (as you’ve probably noticed) the pricing and the time it takes for initial cycling.
This is an overall fantastic product and probably the best substrate on the market, so I give it a 10/10.Advantages:
- Good specific gravity (holds plants well)
- Has key nutrients (for Amazonia types)
- Will grow even difficult plants (for Amazonia types)
- A constant supply of nitrogen through NH4+ (for Amazonia types)
- Good porosity (holds more beneficial bacteria)
- Lowers pH
- Easy management
- Bottom-dweller safe
- Costly (though that’s an investment that will last for over a year)
- Needs replenishing after 12 to 18 months (depends on your plants)
- May need to be cycled, because of high nitrogen release
2. CaribSea Eco-Complete Planted – Common choice
This substrate can be controversial.
CaribSea’s Eco-Complete is (in my experience) rather inert.
They do not lie on the back of the cover, the substrate has the chemicals in it, but not in molecules that would render them available for plant food.
I can cite Tom Barr (a famous guru with significant expertise in planted aquariums) on this matter:
The glass example is on point.
Though dosing the water column with liquid fertilizers is usually beneficial for plants, with Eco-Complete it’s a must.
Root tabs can also make a difference.
I’d classify it as an inert substrate.
The CEC value of this substrate is mediocre as well.
However, what I like about Eco-Complete is its porosity and attractive texture.
It provides a huge bed for beneficial bacteria and it looks really good under plants.
Speaking of which, it comes in bags of water, because it’s pre-cycled.
It’s still a good idea to wait it out a bit, because the colonies may need to grow to support the current levels of ammonia and nitrite that are being produced in your tank.
It does not require rinsing, and it does not make a mess in the tank. All of this makes it a super easy substrate to maintain.
It leans on the lighter side, which means that if you plan on having tender plants it may be difficult to anchor them down from the first time.
Still, roots develop easily and have no issue establishing themselves.
Eco-Complete is safe for bottom-dwellers.
This substrate MAY rise your carbonate hardness (KH) which in turn may increase pH. So be careful if you have shrimps.
The product may also increase the general hardness (GH), so take that into consideration as well.
The manufacturers claim that they fixed the issue, but there are recent reports of it happening again.
This is another reason to test it on a fishless tank at first and wait for the water parameters to stabilize.
A con I would like to mention is the price.
It’s a bit overpriced given its impact on plant growth.
I’d recommend this substrate if you’re after easy aquatic plants.
As long as you pick your plants right you can have a good-looking underwater jungle with no issues.Advantages:
- High porosity
- Good texture
- Moss attaches well, because of the porous surface
- Suitable for easy plants
- Comes pre-cycled
- Safe for bottom-dwellers
- Does not require rinsing
- Easy to manage (no mess)
- Nutrients won’t be enough on their own (needs additional dosing)
- Lightweight (more difficult to plant small plants in it)
- A bit overpriced
- May rise pH and KH
3. Black Diamond Blasting Sand – Novice-Friendly
Image by: MUTigers
I wrote a whole separate article on Black Diamond Blasting Sand.
I recommend you check that, but I’ll summarize what’s important when it comes to planted tanks.
This sand looks gorgeous, the grains are the right size, has a PERFECT specific gravity and is inert.
It will complement the colors of your plants, fish, and shrimp unless they have a darker coloration.
You can choose from either the finer or the medium grade grit.
With the finer one (20/40) your plants will definitely have an easy time staying on the bottom and spreading roots.
With the coarser, medium one (30/60) it would be easier to vacuum and it won’t get stirred as easily by livestock.
This sand is heavy and will not cloud your water for a long time.
Another thing here is the cost.
You can find Black Diamond Blasting Sand locally at Tractor Supply Co and it will cost you 5 times less than if you buy it from a normal supermarket.
You can also get its alternative – Black Beauty Sand, which is very similar in composition.
Both will come at a price of $8 to $10 for a 50 lbs bag.
Cheap price, but not cheap quality for a decent-looking planted tank.
This substrate is perfect for plants with delicate roots.
Its weight and size are as if they were made for aquascaping.
It won’t ever need replenishing and it’s inert.
Just dose with root tabs or liquid fertilizers and your plants will be fine.
My experience has been that with the right light you can even grow carpeting plants on it.
BD blasting sand is an overall great substrate for the aquarium – it’s easy to manage and it looks good.
This is one of the best inert substrates for a planted aquarium, in my opinion.
It’s by far the most economical one, and when combined with root tabs and a little water column dosing your aquatic plants will grow absolutely fine.Advantages:
- Very easy to plant in
- Attractive appearance
- Is heavier and will not cloud water
- Plants with tender roots have an easy time spreading them
- Will not compact
- Easy management
- Perfect for the DIY cap approach
- Sometimes difficult to find it locally (can be found in Tractor Supply Co)
- Is inert (additional fertilizers should be provided)
- May need rinsing before adding it to your tank
4. Mr Aqua Planted Substrate – Long-lasting Growth
Image by: mythin
Mr. Aqua’s aquarium soil is another quality substrate that will deplete over time.
From my experience, you can achieve explosive plant growth with this aquasoil.
Same as ADA Amazonia, it will feed your plants nitrogen through the release of ammonium.
I couldn’t find exact data on how much it would leach, compared to Amazonia, but some hobbyists claim that it’s not as much as ADA’s products.
However, I find Mr. Aqua to be extremely nutritious and in some setups outperforming Amazonia (emphasis on “some”).
This substrate will bring down the water’s pH to around 6.5, making it ideal for a freshwater planted tank with shrimps.
The granules keep their look whole for a long time.
This substrate is roughly the same price as other premium quality aquasoils, but make sure you get the 8L bag because the 1L ones are super overpriced.
Also, do your research on how much bags would you need for your tank.
This Mr. Aqua product has a lower specific gravity, which causes it to be more easily stirred by livestock.
It will cloud your water at first and when rescaping, but with a decently powerful filter it should be fine in a couple of hours.
I recommend capping it with an inert substrate of your choice.
This will solve both the lightweight issue (easing your planting efforts) and the muddy water issue.
Some will say that this substrate has a mediocre look to it, nothing too special. I kind of like it.
It’s an overall great product and if you can find a deal on it – definitely buy it, as it will grow even difficult plants.
I give this substrate a 9/10.Advantages:
- Can grow difficult plants
- Has key nutrients
- Will decrease pH
- A constant supply of Nitrogen
- Grain texture last longer for a depleting substrate
- Is lightweight (I recommend capping it with a heavier substrate)
- Will cloud the water upon introduction or rescaping (another reason to be capped, unless you have a good canister filter)
- You should probably cap it with another substrate
- May need cycling (depending on your current pH)
- Depletes over time (12 to 24 months)
- Greater initial cost (though it’s worth it)
5. Fluval Plant and Shrimp Stratum – For beginner plants
Image by: splinteredmind
Fluval Stratum has key nutrients but won’t leach huge amounts of NH4+ like some other more expensive substrates for freshwater planted tanks.
Aquatic plants grow well in it, though if you’re after some more demanding plants fertilizer dosing would be a must.
It will still buffer down the pH of the water to slightly beneath 6.8, for me it was always around 6.5 or so.
Of course, shrimps do well in it, for as long as the pH remains low.
This aquasoil is safe for bottom dwellers and fish that like to burrow themselves, such as freshwater eels.
The size of the grains in combination with its specific gravity makes it a little difficult to plant smaller plants.
With carpeting plants, you may have a really annoying experience if you don’t cap with another aquarium-suitable substrate with a decent weight.
The grains are also a little more brittle than with other substrates, so be gentle.
It will initially cloud your water, rinsed or not.
With a filter in place, the cloudiness will sort itself out.
Mind that a strong filter such as a canister one may blow the stuff around, so you’d be better off with a HOB.
I recommend this substrate if you’re planning to have a planted shrimp tank, that employs low-demand freshwater plants with big and robust roots.
The pH buffering starts to fade off at around half a year in, but you can extend that period if you use distilled or RO/DI water for water changes.Advantages:
- Will grow low to medium difficulty plants on its own
- Will decrease water pH
- Safe for bottom-dwellers
- Really lightweight (don’t buy if you rescape often)
- Can create a mess (unless capped)
- Depletes after 6 to 8 months (almost twice as fast than other aquasoils)
- Is a little too brittle
6. Dennerle Scaper’s soil – Premium & Balanced
Dennerle Scaper’s soil offers everything an aquarium soil should, except it has ammonium leaching down to a minimum.
Don’t get me wrong, you will definitely get a spike, but it won’t be as dramatic as with ADA Amazonia, for example.
Other than that this product holds up well and arguably longer than any other aquasoil.
It has the key nutrients and your plants will absolutely flourish in it.
It lowers the pH of the water as well.
Letting it cycle is recommended before adding any fish or shrimp.
It’s rather clean (or at least cleaner than most) and management is not difficult.
When rescaping you’ll find it dusting the water (though not mudding) for a short period, so, perhaps, a cap should be used.
The specific gravity of the grains is awesome.
In fact, I think planting is the easiest in this soil than with any other depleting substrate.
It’s not the cheapest, however, but the results are pretty great and for the plant growth you’ll get, my personal opinion is that the price is justified.
Use if you’re willing to spend a little more, but don’t have the nerves to deal with lengthy ammonia spikes and muddy water.
I rate Scaper’s soil at 9.5/10.Advantages:
- Will grow demanding plants
- Planting in it is a breeze
- Won’t mud your water upon rescaping (though it will dust it)
- Buffers pH to below 7
- Ideal for planted shrimp tanks
- Texture holds longer than your usual aquasoil
- Natural look
- Gives off less Nitrogen, but still needs cycling
7. Safe-T-Sorb – Cheaper Alternative
Image by: smellydeli
Safe-T Absorbent also famous as Safe-T Sorb is a very good option as an inert substrate for freshwater live plants.
I did not list other baked-clay products here (Turface MVP, Oil-Dri etc.) because in my experience they were not worth mentioning compared to Safe-T Sorb.
What I like about this product is that you can find it for super cheap, it has a beautiful appearance (if you’re into light-colored substrates) and it doesn’t create nearly as much mess as the others.
If you’ve clicked the Amazon link above you’d see that its price is not something outstanding compared to the others, so why would I list it as a cheap option then?
Well, same as Black Diamond Blasting Sand (reviewed above) it can be found at your local Tractor Supply Co for no more than $10 per 20 lbs bag.
It has the highest CEC value from the other baked clay substrates, which means you can “charge” it with nutrients and not be as diligent with fertilizer dosing.
Note that its CEC is less than a quarter that of an aquasoil.
Still, because of its relatively decent CEC, it will strip your water from kH, which in effect will also lower the pH.
This effect is not constant and it stabilizes itself out in a month or so.
It’s super clean and easy to manage and it allows for rescaping plants and decor to become a pleasure.
Planting very tender plants can be tricky sometimes tough, as the specific gravity is not that convenient for holding them down easily.
Rinse a lot before introducing this substrate to your tank. If you don’t it will create a mess and you won’t be able to enjoy the view of your plants.
I would recommend using this product in your aquarium, if you want an inexpensive quality inert substrate, that’s not black (BDBS), you’re willing to dose fertilizers and you’re after growing plants with larger roots.Advantages:
- Absorbs carbonates and lowers pH and water hardness
- Doesn’t create a mess
- Texture and color (if you’re not into darker aquarium beds)
- Higher CEC (means you can dose fertilizers on a loose schedule)
- RINSE IT
- Additional fertilizers are a must
- Availability (You need to get it from Tractor Supply Co, locally)
- Doesn’t hold small plants and carpets well
8. Seachem Flourite – Aesthetic options
Image: Seachem Flourite Red
Seachem’s Flourite series are various inert aquarium substrates.
Some will have finer particles and some not so much.
They all have a very appealing look and compliment planted tanks well.
There’s a myth circulating the Internet that Flourite has a high CEC value.
I’ve found this to be untrue. Speaking of which it will not alter any of the water parameters.
It’s very chemically stable and it does not lose its texture ever.
It can be perceived as lightweight for some hobbyists’ taste and you may find some of your smaller plants pop up and float after planting.
There are two cons that I would like to discuss here.
This substrate is a real mess if not thoroughly rinsed.
I’m talking 6 to 8 times rinsed.
It can cloud your planted tank’s water for weeks, defeating the purpose of enjoying a nice forest-like aquascape.
Rinse very well.
Another thing to consider is cost.
If you’re not using it in a small aquarium with plants you’ll find yourself paying a fortune for a substrate that has no real impact on plants.
You should definitely dose water column fertilizers AND root tabs if you’re after the Flourite look.
I recommend this substrate only if you like its appearance, and are prepared to rinse well, stay on top of the fertilizing schedule and do not plan to employ small carpeting plants in your aquarium.Advantages:
- Keeps its texture virtually forever
- Good aesthetics
- Lots of texture and color options to choose from
- Can cloud the water if not rinsed very well beforehand
- Inert (your plants will need additional fertilization)
- Don’t use if you plan on having carpeting plants
How much substrate do your plants need: depth & bag weight?
Here’s how deep the substrate for your planted tank should be:
For a planted tank you’d generally want no more than 2 inches of a nutrient-rich depleting substrate or 3 inches of “capped” substrate where 1 inch is your inert cap and the remaining 2 are for the depleting one.
That being said, here’s how to calculate how much substrate would you need to buy for your plants:
The basic formula for calculating aquarium substrates is
(Tank Width cm x Tank Lenght cm x Substrate Depth cm) / 1000.
This equation will give you the substrate needed in liters.
All of this is not an exact science, because different substrates have different density and a liter is a measurement of volume.
Not every bag that you’ll find lists its contents in liters though.
What I like to do when in doubt is use this basic substrate calculator, which takes into account the specific density of the sediments.
Check the dimensions of your aquarium and fill in the empty fields to calculate how many bags of substrate would you need to purchase.
Did you make a choice?
If in doubt, it’s best to consider aesthetics and the level of management before anything. If you’ll not be as diligent with dosing fertilizers to your planted tank go for a depleting substrate, If you’re okay with the schedule choose something that simply looks good.
Start a discussion with me in the comments if you need more advice.