Mystery SOLVED – Is Distilled Water Particularly Good for Fish Tanks?

Using distilled water for your aquarium seems like a good choice because it’s so pure and therefore safer, right?

The best water for aquarium-use should be clean and contain as little contaminants as possible, after all.

It turns out, however, that fish need more than just pure H2O molecules.

So if the water is being purified by distillation does that mean you can’t at all use it in your fish tank?

Are purified and distilled water even the same thing?

Distillation is the process of water being boiled, turned into steam and then cooled down to become liquid again.

What this achieves is all dissolved solids in the impure water are left behind after the evaporation.

The result is (almost) nothing but pure H2O.

Distilled water has the lowest TDS (Total Dissolved Solids) from all types of water.

As you can probably guess TDS is measured in ppm (parts per million) and after high-quality distillation, it will drop to 0.

Is distilled water suitable for fish tanks?

Using water that has gone through distillation in a fish tank can be justified under the following circumstances:

Pure distilled water is good for topping off an aquarium that’s losing water due to evaporation. It has Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) at 0 which makes it the softest water possible.

For this reason, it can also be used for reducing the hardness of tap water before a water change.

Distilled water alone should not be used for water changes.

It has virtually no minerals in it, which makes it harmful to aquatic life.

Minerals are necessary for fish and plants and will also act as a buffer for pH.

With proper remineralization distilled water becomes one of the best options for a healthy aquarium.

That being said, in small tanks and bowls using pure distilled water can be fatal to fish as it will significantly impact pH levels.

Time to expand on that a little.

When NOT to use distilled water in your fish tank?

You should not use distilled water for water changes of your fish tank. The reason for that is its lack of minerals.

When I say minerals I mean mainly magnesium, calcium, and iron among many others. Fish need water that’s rich in these vital elements for optimal health.

Fish and plants alike use minerals in the water, where humans can get all they need from food. Not only that, but minerals will regulate and STABILIZE the pH levels in the water.

Even the slightest pH swing can be fatal to fish.

Years of experience taught me that the key element here is not the value of the number, but its stability.

My fish would adapt to a gradual change of the pH, but a fluctuating one would almost always turn out lethal to them.

Distilled water in its nature has around 7 pH, which makes it slightly acidic.

However, without stabilization, this number will be very unstable as almost every factor that impacts it will force violent fluctuations.

Even carbon absorbed from the air will lower the pH after just a couple of hours after the distillation.

Another reason using pure distilled water for your aquarium is a bad idea is because of its neurological effect on fish.

Many animals use charged particles (ions) from salts for transmitting signals through the nervous system.

When you put a fish in pure distilled or purified water the salts in its body and bloodstream will quickly dissolve in the water, rendering its nervous system seriously damaged.

No betta, goldfish or any other fish species is immune to this effect.

I know this all sounds discouraging and I’m assuming you’re interested in the subject because you’re trying to find a good alternative to your awful tap water.

Sometimes conditioned tap water can be all your fish tank needs, but often its low quality is the reason behind algae growth or simply our fish like it softer.

Worry not.

When can you use distilled water in your aquarium?

You can use distilled water in your fish tank for:

  • Topping off evaporation water losses. The reason you can top off your tank with pure distilled water is that you do not break the mineral balance of your fish tank this way.

    Whatever water has evaporated did not take any minerals with it. They remain where they belong – in your aquarium.

  • Water changes but after remineralization. This is the only way you can make distilled water safe for your fish.

    I could replace tap water with it as long as I properly remineralized it.

    I would add the good minerals back while having the benefit of staying away from everything harmful in my tap water.

    Remineralized distilled water is one of the best water choices for your aquarium.

  • To lower the hardness of your tap water. Mixing a gallon of tap water with a gH of 20 with a gallon of distilled water will leave you with a 10 gH water.

    It’s a misconception that you can use it to proportionally lower the pH of your tap water, however.

    See, pH changes on a logarithmic scale.

    This means that diluting 1 gallon of tap water with a gallon of distilled water will not halve the pH value of your end product.

    What works best here is testing for yourself.

    Carbon hardness (kH) or alkalinity should be taken into consideration as well here.

    With levels of 2.5 to 3, it will prevent any violent fluctuations in the pH and it may even keep it the same value.

    So if your tap water contains a kH of 3, diluting it with distilled water will result in a stable pH and a halved hardness.

Difference between all types of water and which one will work best in your aquarium

It’s important to understand how every type of water is defined as it will improve your judgment when it comes to which one you want to use in your aquarium. Let me clarify what’s the differences between them:

  • Distilled water – This is water that has gone through a distillation process and aims to achieve 0 ppm.

    It is usually at 7 pH, it’s unstable by nature and it has no minerals in it.

    Although the distillation may guarantee 0 TDS some volatile organic compounds and other volatile solvents with a low-boiling point (such as benzene) will evaporate along with the H2O molecules.

    This means distilled-only water does not guarantee lack of contaminants, yet it remains one of the purest types of water.

    It is also the softest one and is dechlorinated by definition.

  • Reverse Osmosis (RO) water – this is a type of water that has been filtered by a semi-permeable membrane and other filters, which removes 90% to 99% of the impurities in it.

    This, again, includes all minerals.

    Osmosis is the process in which any solvent moves through the membrane in a direction that tends to equalize the concentration of the solutes on both sides.

    This happens because of the osmotic pressure.

    In reverse osmosis, there’s an outside pressure applied that overcomes the osmotic pressure and therefore the solvent (in this case the water) moves across the membrane in the opposite direction, winding up on the pressurized side of the membrane.

    The selective membrane traps larger molecules (bacteria included) on the other side of the membrane while allowing the smaller H2O molecules to pass.

    In short, the impurities are too large to enter through the membrane thus the water is purified.

    This method of purification is very cost-effective compared to distillation.

  • De-ionized (DI) water – Special resins capture positively and negatively charged ions from the water.

    The advantage of de-ionized water is that it removes anions like Chlorides and Nitrates completely, unlike RO or distillation.

    Usually, this method is applied along with RO in premade purification units.

    These units have carbon block filters that remove chlorine.

    Unfortunately, they cannot remove chloramine effectively, unless there’s a special separate carbon cartridge, which newer models often have.

  • Purified water – this is any water that has gone under some sort of purification (all aforementioned, included).

    For any water to be classified as purified it needs to have no more than 10 ppm of TDS.

    This is more of a quality classification.

  • Mineral water – Bottled mineral water, by definition, should contain over 250 ppm of TDS of trace minerals.

    It may originate from an underground source.

    It’s usually an RO/DI purified water that has been additionally remineralized after.

  • Spring water – The only requirement for this type of water is that it originates from an underground source around soil and rock beds.

    It may or may not be rich in minerals and as every spring is different, the TDS of trace minerals will greatly vary.

Have a look at which water would best fit the needs of an aquarium:

Using RO/DI water for aquariums

Everything that applies to the distilled water applies here as well, meaning it will need remineralization.

Reverse osmosis and deionized water are very good choices for both freshwater and saltwater users. In fact, saltwater aquarists use them all of the time, as marine life is VERY sensitive to impurities in our tap water.

“Why don’t they use distilled water then?” you may ask.

Well, the truth is they can.

But most companies won’t state how exactly they distil their water and often copper pipes are being used.

Copper is a big no-no for marine life.

Therefore if you want to be sure what you’re putting in your fish tank you’d just need to distil the water on your own.

This, however, may come in costly.

A smart practice is to just get a reliable RO/DI water filtration unit. These cost around $200 (give or take). The one I linked to falls on the inexpensive side, but I know for a fact is a solid choice, because I know a couple of guys that own it and swear by it.

It WILL pay for itself in time because it will save you tons of headaches and anxiety for your fish.

This is especially true for saltwater reef tanks, where fish are super fragile and expensive.

A good reason to switch to remineralized RO/DI water is wanting to control algae growth in your tank (link to the extensive guide I wrote) by limiting phosphate levels.

Using purified water for fish tanks

You can use any purified water in your fish tank as long as you adapt it to the needs of the aquatic life inside.

As stated above “purified” only means that the water went through whatever purifying processes and that it has no more than 10 TDS.

This implies that adding the minerals back and buffering the pH is a must to make it safe for your fish.

Using mineral water for aquariums

The million cents question. Can you put bottled water in a fish tank and what will the aftermath be?

Coincidentally, mineral water is among your best choices for use in a freshwater aquarium with hard water loving fish because everything is done for you.

Companies will filter their product by RO/DI and add minerals afterwards. Bear in mind you’d still have to test the brands and check if the levels of trace minerals are right for your fish.

Also, mineral water may be treated with chlorine or chloramine so it’s a good idea to condition it before adding it to your aquarium.

Mineral water may be a little more expensive as it is mainly imported from Europe.

Using spring water for aquariums

From spring water to spring water there’s a huge difference.

It all depends on the location and origins of these waters so trace minerals will vary greatly.

My advice here is that the trial and error method will be most productive for finding out which brand will work best for your needs.

How to remineralize Purified (distilled and RO/DI) water and make it suitable for your aquarium?

You can surely do it on your own with Epsom salt, calcium chloride, and baking soda.

In my experience, it is way safer (and easier for that matter) if you just use a commercially available product.

I am pretty happy with Seachem Equilibrium because it does not contain phosphates so it favors planted tanks.

If yours is not planted you can go with Seachem Replenish. Saltwater users can simply add a salt mix which will do the job.

92.57% of the readers found this article helpful.

Tap a star to leave your vote:

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (35 votes, average: 4.63 out of 5)

Loading...

I think you'll also like

Leave a Reply

avatar

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  Subscribe  
Notify of